LEGAL CAPACITY AND HUMAN DIGNITY – CRITICAL REMARKS ON INCAPACITATION IN POLISH LAW IN A COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVE
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25234/pv/34133Keywords:
legal capacity, intellectual disorder, intellectual disability, incapacitationAbstract
The provisions of the Polish Civil Code concerning legal capacity, including the institution of incapacitation, similarly to other countries in the region, have not undergone major changes since their entry into force on January 1, 1965. Over the years the state of medical knowledge, the perception of various mental illnesses and dysfunctions, as well as the social role of people with disabilities have evolved radically. The systemic context – both constitutional and international (conventional) – as well as the legal state-of-play in this area in most Western European countries, including those which were the regulatory model for the Polish legislator, have also changed. Against this background, the Author advocates the need to abolish the institution of incapacitation and replace it with more nuanced and proportionate legal measures that do not interfere as profoundly with legal capacity and thus with legally protected human dignity. This request is finally being realised by the draft law on instruments for supported decision-making of December 9, 2024.
References
Bach M, ‘The right to legal capacity under the UN Convention on the rights of persons with disabilities: Key concepts and directions from law reform, Institute for Research and Development on Inclusion and Society (2009)
Balwicka-Szczyrba M and Sylwestrzak A, ‘Instytucja ubezwłasnowolnienia w perspektywie unormowań Konstytucji RP oraz konwencji ONZ o prawach osób niepełnosprawnych’ (2018) XL Gdańskie Studia Prawnicze 151
Bilikiewicz T, Psychiatria kliniczna (PZWL 1966)
Bruce A, Burke C, Castellino J, Degener T, Kenna P, Kilkelly U, Quinlivan S, Quinn G, in: G Quinn, T Degener (ed.), ‘Human Rights and Disability. The current use and future potential of United Nations human rights instruments in the context of disability, United Nations (2002)
Craigie J, Bach M, Gurbai S, Kanter A, Kim S, Lewis O, Morgan G, ‘Legal capacity, mental capacity and supperted decision making: Report from a panel event’ (2019) 62 International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 162
Dhanda, A, ‘Legal capacity in the disability rights convention: stranglehold of the past or lodestar for the future?’, (2006–2007) 34 Syracuse Journal of International Law and Commerce 429
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, DSM-IV (by American Psychiatric Society / Association).
Domański M, ‘Ubezwłasnowolnienie w prawie polskim a wybrane standardy międzynarodowej ochrony praw człowieka’ (2004) 17 Prawo w Działaniu. Sprawy Cywilne 7
Drobot J, ‘Ubezwłasnowolnienie całkowite na tle rozwiązań europejskich’ (2020) 1 Radca Prawny. Zeszyty Naukowe 115
Góraj A, ‘Wpływ ubezwłasnowolnienia na losy osób ubezwłasnowolnionych’ (1982) XVI Psychiatria Polska, 39
Gutowski M, ‘Art. 13’ in: M Gutowski (ed), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz, vol. I (C.H. Beck 2021)
Hellmann U, ‘Selbstbestimmungsrecht, rechtliche Betreuung, Handlungsfähigkeit und Geschäfts(un)fähigkeit – wie passt das zusammen?’, (2004) 4 Verbandsdienst der Lebenshilfe, 174
Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights, Incapacitation under constitutional and international standards for human rights protection (2018)
International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, ICD-10 (by World Health Organization).
Kalus S, ‘Art. 13’ in: M Habdas and M Fras (eds), Komentarz do Kodeksu cywilnego (Wolters Kluwer 2018)
Kalus S, ‘Opieka nad osobą całkowicie ubezwłasnowolnioną’ (1989) 1033 , Prace Naukowe Uniwersytetu Śląskiego w Katowicach 51
Kociucki L, ‘Zdolność do czynności prawnych osób dorosłych i jej ograniczenia’, (C.H. Beck 2011)
Księżak P, ‘Art. 12’ in: K Osajda (ed), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz (C.H. Beck 2021)
Księżak P, ‘Art. 13’ in: K Osajda (ed), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz (C.H. Beck 2021)
Larenz K and Wolf M, Allgemeiner Teil des Bürgerlichen Rechts (C.H. Beck 1997)
Larribau-Terneyre V, Droit Civil: Introduction, Bien, Personnes, Famille (Dalloz 2018)
Ludwiczak L, Ubezwłasnowolnienie w polskim systemie prawnym (Lexis Nexis 2012)
Machnikowski P, ‘Instytucja opieki nad pełnoletnim w pracach Komisji Kodyfikacyjnej Prawa Cywilnego w latach 2012–2015’ (2019) 4 Państwo i Prawo 135
Machnikowski P, ‘Pełnomocnictwo opiekuńcze w pracach Komisji Kodyfikacyjnej Prawa Cywilnego w latach 2012–2015’ (2016) 4 Rejent 50
Markiewicz I and others, ‘Ubezwłasnowolnienie – instytucja nadal potrzebna?’ (2014) 11 (4) 203
Medicus D, Allegmeiner Teil des BGB. Ein Lehrbuch (C.F. Müller 2002)
Paprzycki L, ‘Psychiatryczno-neurologiczno-psychologiczne aspekty postępowania cywilnego w przedmiocie ubezwłasnowolnienia – zagadnienia prawne’ (2009) 1–2 Palestra 9
Pasieka-Kuzara M, ‘Bliski koniec instytucji ubezwłasnowolnienia?’ (2021) 2 Transformacje Prawa Prywatnego 85
Pilich M, ‘Art. 13’ in: Jacek Gudowski (ed), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz, vol. I, part 1 (Lexis Nexis 2021)
Pudzianowska D, (ed), Prawa osób z niepełnosprawnością intelektualną lub psychiczną w świetle międzynarodowych instrumentów ochrony praw człowieka (Wolters Kluwer 2014)
Series L, ‘Disability and human rights’, in: N. Watson and S Vehmas (eds), Routledge Handbook of Disability Studies, Routledge Taylor & Francis Group (2020)
Serwach M, ‘Art. 13’ in: M Pyziak-Szafnicka and P Księżak (eds), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz (Wolters Kluwer 2014)
Strugała R, ‘Art. 11’ in: E Gniewek and P Machnikowski (eds), Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz (C.H. Beck 2021)
Szeroczyńska M, ‘Ubezwłasnowolnienie i alternatywne formy pomocy w realizowaniu zdolności do czynności prawnych osób z niepełnosprawnością intelektualną, w regulacjach międzynarodowych oraz w prawie obcym, na przykładzie Estonii, Niemiec, Szwecji, Wielkiej Brytanii i Kanady (stanu Manitoba)’ in: K Kędziora (ed), Jeśli nie ubezwłasnowolnienie, to co? Prawne formy wsparcia osób z niepełnosprawnością intelektualną (PTPA 2012)
Szwed M, ‘Likwidacja konstrukcji ubezwłasnowolnienia w Gruzji po wyroku Sądu Konstytucyjnego z 8 października 2014 r.’ (2017) 1 Przegląd Legislacyjny 65
REGULATIONS AND DOCUMENTS
The Act of February 25, 1964 – Family and Guardianship Code (consolidated text: Journal of Laws 2023, item 2809)
The Act of April 23, 1964 – Civil Code (consolidated text: Journal of Laws 2023, item 1610, as amended)
The Act of November 17, 1964 – Code of Civil Procedure (consolidated text: Journal of Laws 2023, item 1550, as amended)
The Act of June 26, 1974 – Labour Code (consolidated text: Journal of Laws 2023, item 1465, as amended)
The Act of August 19, 1994 on the protection of mental health (consolidated text: Journal of Laws 2018, item 1878, as amended)
The Act of May 9, 2007 amending the Act – Code of Civil Procedure and certain other acts (Journal of Laws No. 121, item 831) and the Act December 17, 2009 amending the Act – Code of Civil Procedure and certain other acts (Journal of Laws of 2010, No. 7, item 45)
The Act of August 18, 1896 – German Civil Code (German: Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch; BGBl. 2002, Teil I, p. 42), last amended by the law of October 10, 2024
Austrian Civil Code (Allgemeines bürgerliches Gesetzbuch) introduced by the imperial patent of June 1, 1811 (JGS 1811, No. 946), last amended by the law of September 9, 2021 (BGBl. Teil I 2021, No. 175)
The Act of December 10, 1907 – Swiss Civil Code (Schweizerisches Zivilgesetzbuch; BBl. 1907 VI 589)
French Civil Code (Code civil) introduced by the Act of 21 March 1804 on the unification of civil laws into a single body (Bulletin des lois de la République française, Series 3, No. B. 354, No. 3677, p. 696), last amended by Ordonnance No. 2021–1192 of 15 September 2021. (JORF No 0216 of 16 September 2021)
The Act of June 26, 1997 – Civil code of Georgia (Parliamentary Gazette, 31, June 24, 1997)
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the UN General Assembly on December 10, 1948
The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, adopted by the UN General Assembly on December 16, 1966
The International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, adopted by the UN General Assembly on December 16, 1966
The Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms concluded in Rome on November 4, 1950
The Charter on Fundamental Rights of the European Union proclaimed at Strasbourg on December 12, 2007, by the European Parliament, the Council and the Commission (Official Journal of the European Union C 303 of December 12, 2007, p. 1)
UN Convention of the Rights of the Child, drawn up in New York on November 20, 1989 (Journal of Laws No. 120, item 526)
UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, drawn up in New York on December 13, 2006 (Journal of Laws of 2012, item 1169)
Recommendation No. R (99)4 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe of February 23, 1999, on principles concerning the legal protection of adults with disabilities
Recommendation No. (2006)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe of April 5, 2006 – Action plan to promote the rights and full participation of persons with disabilities in society: enhancing the quality of life of persons with disabilities in Europe 2006–2015
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties of May 23, 1969 (Journal of Laws 1990, No. 74, item 439)
JUDGMENTS
Appeal Court of Kraków of 25 February 2015, I Aca 1751/14
Polish Supreme Court II CR 32/68 (23 February 1968)
Polish Supreme Court II CR 138/72 (18 May 1972)
Polish Supreme Court II CR 787/74 (13 January 1975)
Polish Supreme Court II CR 471/76 (25 November 1976)
Polish Supreme Court I CSK 122/13 (17 May 2013)
Polish Supreme Court I CSK 331/17 (6 September 2017)
Polish Supreme Court III CZP 38/16 (28 September 2016)
Shtukaturov v Russia, no 44009/05 (ECHR, 27 March 2008)
Salontaji-Drobnjak v Serbia, no 36500/05 (ECHR, 13 October 2009).
Glor v Switzerland, no 13444/04 (ECHR, 30 April 2009)
Alajos Kiss v Hungary, no 38832/06 (ECHR, 20 May 2010)
X and Y v Croatia, no 5193/09 (ECHR, 3 November 2011)
Stanev v Bulgaria, no 36760/06 (ECHR, 17 January 2012)
Sykora v Czech Republic, no 23419/07 (ECHR, 22 November 2012)
Kędzior v Poland, no 45026/07 (ECHR, 16 October 2012)
K.C. v Poland, no 31199/12 (ECHR, 25 November 2014)
INTERNET SOURCES
Bach M and Kerzner L, ‘A New Paradigm for Protecting Autonomy and the Right to Legal Capacity. Advancing Substantive Equality for Persons with Disabilities through Law, Policy and Practice’ (2010) Law Commission of Ontario <https://www.lco-cdo.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/disabilities-commissioned-paper-bach-kerzner.pdf> accessed 19 January 2025
Civil Law Codification Commission, Draft guidelines for the amendment of the Civil Code, Civil Procedure Code, Family and Guardianship Code and other acts regarding the legal capacity of persons with mental disabilitiesi (in polish: Komisja Kodyfikacyjna Prawa Cywilnego, Projekt założeń nowelizacji Kodeksu cywilnego, Kodeksu postępowania cywilnego, Kodeksu rodzinnego i opiekuńczego i innych ustaw w zakresie zdolności do czynności prawnych osób z niepełnosprawnością psychiczną) <https://bip.ms.gov.pl/Data/Files/_public/kkpc/projekty-na-stroniems/1-zalozenia-v--2-0-22-03-2013-do-dprc.doc> accessed 19 January 2025
Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, Who gets to decide? Right to legal capacity for persons with intellectual and psychosocial disabilities Council of Europe (2012) <https://rm.coe.int/who-gets-to-decide-right-to-legal-capacity-for-persons-with-intellectu/16807bb0f9> accessed 19 January 2025
Directorate General for International Policies, Comparative Study on the legal systems of the protection of adults lacking legal capacity. National Rules of Private Law, of Private International Law and Possible Legislative Initiative of the European Union: United Kingdom, France, Germany, Sweden, Czech Republic, Romania, European Parliament, Brussels (2008), prepared by the Swiss Institute of Comparative Law <http://www.europarl.europa.eu/stidies> accessed 7 March 2025
European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, Legal capacity of persons with intellectual disabilities and persons with mental health problems, Publications Office of the European Union, Luxemburg (2013)
Green Paper Optimal Vision of the Civil Code in the Republic of Poland (in polish: Zielona Księga Optymalna wizja Kodeksu cywilnego w Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej), Civil Law Codification Commission of the Minister of Justice (2006) <http://bip.ms.gov.pl/kkpc/zielona_ksiega.pdf> accessed 19 January 2025
Open Society Institute, „Rights of People with Intellectual Disabilities. Access to Education and Employment – Poland”, 2005, <https://www.refworld.org/reference/countryrep/osi/2005/en/43345> accessed 19 January 2025
Polish Constitutional Tribunal K 28/05 (7 March 2007) <https://ipo.trybunal.gov.pl/ipo/view/sprawa.xhtml?&pokaz=dokumenty&sygnatura=K%2028/05> accessed 19 January 2025
Records of guardianship cases in district courts - first instance from 2004 to 2018 and in the first half of 2019i (in Polish: Ewidencja spraw o ubezwłasnowolnienie w sądach okręgowych – I instancja w latach 2004–2018 oraz w I półroczu 2019 r.) <https://isws.ms.gov.pl/pl/baza-statystyczna/opracowania-wieloletnie/> accessed 19 January 2025
Report of European Study: ‘The Specific Risks of Discrimination Against Persons in Situation of Major Dependence or With Complex Needs’ vol. 3, “Country Reports and Stakeholders Interviews” (2006) <https://disability-studies.leeds.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/40/library/inclusion-europe-inclusion-europe-3.pdf> accessed 19 January 2025
Statement of the Ombudsman in a case pending before the Constitutional Court, SK 23/18 (Pismo procesowe Rzecznika Praw Obywatelskich złożone w sprawie zawisłej przed Trybunałem Konstytucyjnym, SK 23/18) <https://www.rpo.gov.pl/sites/default/files/Stanowisko%20RPO%20dla%20TK%20w%20sprawie%20ubezw%C5%82asnowolnienia.pdf> accessed 19 January 2025
World Health Organization, ‘World Report on Disability 2011’ <https://www.who.int/teams/noncommunicable-diseases/sensory-functions-disability-and-rehabilitation/world-report-on-disability> accessed 5 March 2025
Zima-Parjaszewska Monika, „Ubezwłasnowolnienie w świetle Konstytucji RP oraz Konwencji o prawach osób z niepełnosprawnościami”, Polskie Towarzystwo Prawa Antydyskryminacyjnego, <https://ptpa.org.pl/site/assets/files/1028/ekspertyza_osi_-_ubezwlasnowolnienie.pdf> accessed 19 January 2025
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Andrzej Herbet
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Authors retain the copyright on the papers published in the Journal, but grant the right of first publication to the Journal. Papers accepted for publication or already published in Pravni vjesnik of the Faculty of Law in Osijek may be published by the author(s) in other publications only with proper notice of its previous publication in Pravni vjesnik.
